Plastic Plants: The Least Common Factor
by Steve Coach, of San Diego
When Benjamin Franklin said, "The least common thing is common sense," he
must have been referring to his aquarium plantscape plastic plants.
As bio-wheel filtration has prevailed and conventional wisdom has leaned toward a
lesser and lesser substrate (bottom gravel) the manufacturers of plastic aquarium plants
continue to produce plants that are not well adapted to current trends. As home
aquarium-keeping is currently so vast and growing one can only wonder at the thinking of
those suppliers. To their credit, the best producers of plastic plants are achieving some
very realistic approximations, but that is not the main problem.
In defense of the use of plastic plants I can only say this: After extensive research
and a lot of eco-system problems in my own tanks - attempting in vain to maintain the most
perfectly balanced aquarium environments I could, I have decided that live plants was not
the best solution. First, let me say that if you have a thriving tank full of live aquatic
botanicals, congratulations to you.
I found that the plants caused increased acid and ammonia. Plant fertilizers, no matter
what I seemed to use, added yet another layer of complexity. The plants have their own
decay, but the bits the fish pulled off didn't help. Keeping the intake baskets free of
loose plant debris was another issue.
After noting none of the local tropical fish retailers in my area used live plants in
their tanks, I headed for the Internet to see how the extremely meticulously controlled
laboratory aquarists dealt with the issue. To my surprise I eventually discovered a
bulletin board (Internet discussion board) where the forum was exactly the issue of live
plants in the aquarium. It seems that around the world where professionally maintained
research lab aquarists study aspects of freshwater tropical fish, live plants are almost
universally considered a hindrance to maintaining a quality controlled aquarium
My experience with fish is that they enjoy the plants. I also noticed that they are not
overly particular about plastic plants versus real plants. Given a tank with no plants
versus plastic only, I decided on plastic.
Problem is that I use a very thin substrate (and no under-gravel filter). So how does
one "root" plastic plants with only ╝" to 3/8" of gravel - and still
make them appear natural?
Plastic plants are typically purchased with some kind of plastic "anchor" at
the base. This anchor is supposedly covered by the tank's substrate. When you have 2"
or 3" of substrate this may not be an issue. But then you may have a more serious
time trying to keep that much gravel clean and detoxified. The idea of a thinner gravel
layer is that the tank's filters, bottom feeders, and bacteria work better when the
substrate is not as deep.
You have a few options. With a thin substrate you can heap up a pile of substrate to
bury the overly large plastic base that is intended by the manufacturers to help anchor
the plastic plant. That looks very unnatural to say the least, and can be a source of tank
putrification as toxins build up in the gravel pile. You could just position an ornamental
rock (or other suitable item) in front of the base to cover it up, but then you still need
to figure out how to keep the plastic plant fixed at the bottom. That's when I came up
with my solution.
When all else fails, make up a solution! I decided that if the large plastic anchors
were the problem, they had to go. I tried my idea and it works very well.
Simply remove the large old plastic bases and replace them using suction cups - the
kind typically used for air-tubing holders (see below).
But what do you do with the plastic plants that had "stems" too awkward to
easily get away with a suction cup, like this one?
Simple. I got out the trusty hot glue gun and grabbed some spare aquarium gravel and
went to work. In short order I had a solution. When it works out right it looks something
When it doesn't work out right, it looks like this:
Care needs to be taken with the hot glue gun as the plastic used for plastic plants has
a fairly low melting point. Damage to the plastic plant can easily result if not careful.
Consider working in a well-ventilated area and/or use a fan. Another thing to consider is
that you use a glue stick that is "non-toxic" for the sake of your fish.
So how does the finished plant look?
You will find it easiest when placing the newly converted plastic plants in your tank
if you first clear a small space in the gravel for the suction cup and place it prior to
attaching the plastic plant. It will be easier to move the suction cup if you want to, and
it will make it easier to keep from knocking off the freshly glued gravel from the plant.
If you do happen to knock some gravel off simply remove and dry the plastic plant. When
dry grab your glue gun and have another go. A little patience works wonders.
So how does a tank look when the plastic plants have all been converted and are put in
Note the shallow gravel substrate along the front edge of the tank.
How do the fish like the new plastic plants? Just ask them!